well, this tuppence worth might be a bit too late in the day but rather than starting my own thread when I saw this one I thought it would be worth contributing to some of the thoughts I have read here.
I have just purchased an ex-demonstator 2005 MY. I previously had a 2003 RX300SE and a Audit TT 225bhp roadster. Both have now gone and been replaced by the SC.
In arriving at the decision my wife and I had a few "must haves" in our mix of boxes to be ticked. These included, in no particular order, - it had to be fun, fast, practical, preferably a convertible, have the ability to seat 4 at a push when needed, and lastly to be special.
After considering lots of cars including, Audi S4 convertible, Jaguar XKR, Mercs (yuck!), BMW M3 convertible (what?!) and a few others we whittled our selection down to a Maserati Coupe (4200), Porsche 911 (996 C4) and the SC. We test drove all three. Only Lexus Edinburgh (thank you Simon!) gave us the car for an extended period.
In summary, the Porsche was nothing special - sacrilege you scream! But frankly, it isn't. The 996 is not the car I had hoped for, Yes, it is a bit iconic and still looks good, but no, it wasn't "special", couldn't seat 4 (even kids) and I refused to buy the compromised convertible. So it was out (much to my dismay and suprise!). I don't believe it is that much different from the TT - a bit quicker but it handles similarly and we wanted it to be so much more. A GT3 though........hmmmm!
The Maser was awesome :D :P - just wonderful. 400bhp and a f1 gear box that worked a treat. 4 proper seats and a heritage and image to die for. fast? oooooooh yes! But, not a convertible, not even a sunroof (so what......just remember that engine!) but at the end of the day the 15mpg and the service costs of £750 for a basic coupled with the fact that this was to be a daily drive and our only car meant even I couldn't let me heart win out over my head.
so that ladies and gentlemen is where the Lexus came in........a premium brand, every extra under the sun, reasonable mpg, reliability and a standard of dealer service (well definitely in Edinburgh) that is second to absolutely none. In addition, that folding tin top is great, the power delivery through the V8 engine is soooo smooth. I can forgive the fact that this is not a sports car, Lexus don't pretend it is. Rather it is a grand tourer that just ooozes class and quality and begs you to hop in for a nice blast down the autobahn to Switzerland and then on to the Riviera.....oh, yes, I fell for it!
So, in answer to your question, you have here one happy owner - one that "offered" to drive back in to the city tonight to pick up the missus who was workign late just so I could put the top down and go for a cruise with a bit of Faithless blasting out on the Mark Levinson (oops, forgot to mention the hi fi didn't I ;) ). One that is now on his third Lexus.
Yes, the earlier cars suffered a reputation of poor handling but more recent ones are reputedly markedly improved. If you can, stretch a wee bit. If you can't, then maybe, just maybe, there is a Maser 3200 out there with your name on it!?!?
oh, and finally, because the car has a tracker I have almost halved my insurance!
all the best.