Update;
I thought I was on an upward curve and even managed to get an average of 41.8mpg after an 84 mile (mainly) motorway run (I had disconnected my battery for a few hours), but no the car has actually got much worse - it is so frustrating, as it is costing me money to do business miles!!
After the hight point I then watched my average mpg drop to around 37.8 mpg after a combination of further out-of-town runs, and then a couple of short trundling to work days (only 8 miles).I then added the BG 244 treatment and thought my problem would be solved. Well, the treated tank achieved 36.9 mpg, despite mainly motorway/ A road driving at no more than 75 mph. I added the AR640 and after the first 128 miles (more than half of which was on motorways or A roads once again) my tank average is now running at 32.8MPG, and I only managed 34.1mpg after a steady 65 miles on the motorway. The computer is saying I'l get about 460 from this tank!!
Frankly, this is just complete and utter pants!!
Some observations;
My car either runs o.k and goes quite well if you give it a fair amount of throttle, or you can feel that it is on the throttle and has the torque you would expect. When it has run well and achieved good figures, it will pull 3rd gear around roundabouts and 70mph in 6th gear - it also feels effortless and really goes if you do give it the beans (pulling well from about 1400rpm)! Mostly, however, you can feel that it doesn't run too well on a light throttle and you can make it choke, whereby when you feel the kick is not there you can then push the throttle and it will rev in a linear fashion without any major push - much like a petrol.
I haven't checked my EGR , as I hoped the fuel treatments would clean this (and all the other bits they purport to clean ) gradually. I believe that the problem is elsewhere, as sometimes it seems to clear itself after it has idled in traffic - my BMW disliked this - and other times you can feel it come back on the throttle when you're going at a steady speed of say 40mph in 3rd gear, or 55mph in 4th gear.
I haven't read (thus far) that there are major turbo problems with the IS220d, or many issues relating to the MAF/MAP for that matter, but I wonder whether it is potentially one of these items and the main problem is that the car manages to run well enough for most owners to just carry on regardless - with poor fuel consumption being the main issue! Usually, when these items are faulty in other diesels they tend to run very poorly, so it is very noticeable. My BMW has a sticky actuator for quite a while (happened rarely to begin with over 35k, but steadily got worse) and I wonder if my IS220d has the same fault, as it just doesn't seem to be boosting correctly for the majority of the time. On e46 3 series the actuator is mechnical and is difficult to check, whereas the 2005 onwards(e90) 3 series has an electric system - I understand this can be checked/activated when the engine is off. What system does the IS220d use - does anyone know?
As a side note, we treated my wife's 2007 Golf gti to the AR 6400 (and then the AR6200), and yes you can feel the difference. The fuel consumption has gone up to a 30.4mpg average, but more importantly it has improved in 400 miles of local driving more so than it did in 600 miles of motorway driving before the treatments. My wife has achieved just under 36mpg during her 18 mile commute on B roads/urban roads , even allowing for rush hour traffic. I get less mpg and my car feels fairly gutless, whereas her car is now straining at the leash - the throttle response is incredible now!
Any thoughts would be most welcome!!