tbh I think they looks very similar :)
cant really notice any difference....
Right, let's try again:
One is just vinil with 3m adhesive right? The other one is woven material just like the real thing and it requires some sort of adhesive that can be 3M as well.
I reckon the one listed would give you the feel and look of dry carbon fiber, where the vinyl will give you just the look. However, they both look good but I guess it comes down to personal preference to whether you want the very close to real thing or just close.