Depends who does it and how much of the old is removed I would suggest. There's some excellent welders out there, and some mediocre ones, and some rubbish ones.
Yup but unless your an expert welder how would you know The one I employed was supposed to be good but it started to blow again within days hence the replacement of the Y sections
The same thing happened on my MK2, welded, fine for a week, and then started blowing again, but they didn't remove any old sections. The garage where I took mine recently also make their own complete systems so I have more confidence in them knowing what they're doing. I did expect them to make a whole Y piece but they said it didn't need it in my case. Time will tell, and if I'm wrong I've got a great recipe for humble pie, I'll come down to Dorset and you can watch me eat it!
Phil