I loved my previous 2 BMW's especially my M3
My major gripes with owning a BMW were the following;
The cost of servicing is very expensive.
However BMW have adressed this with a four plus scheme for older cars (four years and older). This does help reduce the servicing costs. I luckily however had an Independent BMW Specialist near to my place of work, servicing here was much cheaper as were parts.
I dont believe getting my car serviced by the specialist harmed the resale value at all. Although I'm sure it would have, had the car not been 6 six years old at time of resale (still mint though :D ).
I am pretty sure as well that newer BMW's service intervals are now nearer 12K than the 10K that they used to be.
My other main gripe would be the standard spec - this does seem very poor when compared with my Lex. My first BMW (318iS) had no leather and only a sunroof, no aircon. My M3 however was fully loaded, as you would expect for a range topping motor. I do think however that BMW should up the spec for cars lower down the range.
I always found the BMW dealerships I went to, to be very friendly and helpfull.
My reason for selling my 318iS (having spent about 3K on Mods :( ) was to buy the M3 I always loved the car.
My reasons for selling the M to buy the Lex were the following; group 20 insurance, servicing every 8K miles (I do about 2K miles a month ) No discounted servicing as M not included in 4plus scheme, and I needed the dealer stamp to keep my warranty, so no independent specialist.
I would never slag BMW off to anyone, as I enjoyed owning both of my previous cars.
All I hope is that my previous BMW dealership experiences, are at least matched when I take my Lex in for a service in a couple of months (including new wheels :) ).
From reading what people have posted, I believe they will.
Apologies for the novel.
All in all Andy I would say for the age you are looking at, you would probably find a nice BMW, and also have more to choose from.
But then I love my Lex - unfortunately for you I don't think the IS200 goes back
before '99. :(
Have I confused you enough yet :D
Happy hunting anyway Andy.
Paul